Administrative and Public Law

"This niche Birmingham firm is well regarded for its work representing individuals in human rights claims. It enjoys a strong reputation for its representation of claimants affected by the \war on terror, having acted for Iraqi civilians and the families of British soldiers killed in Iraq. The firm has expertise in international human rights law and acts for Daoud Mousa and nine others in the Baha Mousa public inquiry."

KEY INDIVIDUALS Philip Shiner leads the team and is considered to be "committed, driven, determined and admirable."

Band 1 (Philip Shiner)

Band 2 (Firm)


Civil Liberties

"This public law firm is renowned for its cutting-edge work defending the human rights of individuals connected to the Iraq war. It recently won success in the landmark ECHR case which condemned the UK government for breaching international human rights law for subjecting two Iraqis to the fear of execution in Iraq."

"KEY INDIVIDUALS Philip Shiner is an outstanding civil liberties solicitor who handles "terrific, ground-breaking cases" and "never gives up fighting for his clients." Dan Carey has emerged as a force in his own right. He is praised for his involvement in significant human rights cases including Al-Sweady, Evans, Al-Haq and the Baha Mousa Inquiry."

Star Rating (Philip Shiner)

Associate to Watch (Dan Carey)

Band 2 (Firm)

Chambers and Partners
 
 

Islamic Republic News Agency: UK Government Forced to Defend Tuition Fees Rise in Court

Friday 24 June 2011, Islamic Republic News Agency
 

Two sixth of students have won permission from the High Court for a legal challenge to prevent the British government from allowing universities to treble tuition fees to £9,000 a year from September 2012

 

The legal action is brought by the 16-year-old Callum Hurley and the 17-year- old Katy Moore and following Thursday's ruling the claim now proceeds to a full hearing at which the government will be forced to defend and justify its decision to increase university fees.

 

Their solicitor Phil Shiner of Public Interest Lawyers (PIL) said the ruling was “a major breakthrough! and that the case “affects the next generations of students from less well off backgrounds.”

 

“This case challenges the government’s bare-faced agenda to make our society one based on elitism and wealth,” Shiner said in a statement obtained by IRNA.

 

The legal challenge is being brought on two grounds, firstly that the increase breaches Article 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights, in particular that it discriminates against students from poorer social origin and ethnic minorities.

 

The second is that the government has failed to give “due regard” to promoting equality of opportunity as is required under the country’s Race Relations, Sex Discrimination and Disability Discrimination Acts.

 

Hurley said he was delighted at the decision. “It is such an important issue that will affect thousands of people and hinder the chances of poorer students who want to go to university,” he said.

 

Moore also welcomed the ruling and said it was “vital that we stand up for our generation and fight the government's decision to almost triple university tuition fees.”

 

“We students are being let down by the government, as these changes to university fees will cause many bright and talented students from poorer backgrounds to be put off going to university due to the thought of thousands and thousands of pounds of debt,” she said.

 

“The government should be taking progressive measures to encourage more young people from state schools to go on to higher education, not making it more difficult for us to achieve the futures we want to achieve,” she added.

 

The increase is expected to leave student incurring debts of upwards of £40,000 by studying for a basic degree with fears that it will deter many from going to university.

 

OIL said that if the case is won and the court squashes the new regulation, it will leave the coalition government's tuition fees policy “in tatters.”

 

Shiner's colleague, Sam Jacobs said the government had “dreamt up the policy of trebling tuition fees in a matter of weeks following the October 2010 spending review.”

 

“It was inevitable that it would fail to meet its legal duties to properly consider equality of opportunity and provide clear justification for restricting access to education,” Jacobs said.

 

“Any assertion that £50,000 to £60,000 of debt does not create an access problem can only be made by someone with their head in the sand,” he said.

 

Last week, PIL won a High Court injunction preventing Gloucestershire County Council from planned library closures, which have also been caused by government public spending cuts and austerity measures.
 


Other stories

Click on a story to read

  Appeal in legal challenge to cuts to North Somerset youth services will be heard on 13 June 2013...
  Claimants launch legal challenge to DWP’s emergency retrospective legislation ...
  PUBLIC INTEREST LAWYERS: UK’S USE OF DRONES IN AFGHANISTAN “HIGHLY LIKELY” TO BREACH INTERNATIONAL ...
  PIL: Afghans 'unlawfully held' by UK forces at Camp Bastion to be transferred to Afghan authorities...
  Public Interest Lawyers' Response to Ministry of Justice Consultation on proposed reforms to legal a...
  Guardian: Camp Bastion detainees challenge the notion of British justice in Afghanistan...
  AFGHANS 'UNLAWFULLY HELD' BY UK FORCES AT CAMP BASTION...
  HIGH COURT RULES IN HUNDREDS OF IRAQI UNLAWFUL KILLINGS AND TORTURE CASES...
  BBC: Baha Mousa book and Marie Colvin honoured by Orwell Prize ...
  HIGH COURT GRANTS PERMISSION TO PROCEED WITH JUDICIAL REVIEW IN AFGHAN KILLINGS CASE...
  Guardian: British soldier under investigation for murder over shooting of young Afghans...
  Guardian: Labour abstention on workfare bill prompts party infighting...
  The Independent: First Al-Sweady witnesses to appear...
  DWP seeks law change to avoid benefit repayments after Poundland ruling...
  Judicial Review launched against Birmingham City Council over cuts to "Shelforce" - a supported disa...
  The Times: Lawyer of the week – Tessa Gregory...
  BBC: Al-Sweady inquiry opens in UK into deaths of Iraqis...
  Birmingham City Council threatened with Judicial Review proceedings over cuts to 'Shelforce' - a sup...
  Open Democracy: Home Secretary, please call off the attack on kidney patient Roseline Akhalu ...
  Court of Appeal Rules that the Government’s “Back to Work” Regulations are Unlawful and Must Be Quas...
  Verdict on Government’s “Back to Work” schemes will be handed down tomorrow, Tuesday 12 February 201...
  Verdict on Government’s “Back to Work” schemes will be handed down on Tuesday 12 February 2013 at 10...