“We wish to pay tribute to the way the case has been handled by all concerned, albeit after a slow start on the part of the Secretary of State.” (per Lord Justice Richards in R (on the application of Maya Evans) v The Secretary of State for Defence [2010] EWHC 1445 (Admin))

Lord Justice Richards
 
 

The Guardian: Teenagers Begin High Court Challenge Against Tuition Fee Rise

Lawyer for two 17-year-olds will argue decision to let universities almost treble fees contravenes human rights and equality laws

Two teenagers have begun a case in the high court against the government's decision to let universities almost treble tuition fees next year.

Callum Hurley and Katy Moore, both 17, argue that the decision to raise fees to up to £9,000 a year from next autumn contravenes human rights and equality legislation.

Their case is expected to last two days and has been paid for through legal aid and pro bono work.

Sam Jacobs, representing the students for Public Interest Lawyers of Birmingham, said there were two grounds for bringing the case.

He will argue first that the rise in fees is in breach of the right to education protected in the Human Rights Act 1998. That right does not guarantee free higher education, but it does place curbs on steps that limit access to higher education, he will tell the court.

He will also argue that the government failed to give "due regard" to promoting equality of opportunity as required under the Race Relations, Sex Discrimination and Disability Discrimination Acts.

Female, disabled people and ethnic minority graduates tend to earn less over their lifetime than male, non-disabled, white graduates, Jacobs will say.

The case, which is being heard by Mr Justice King and Lord Justice Elias, has been urged to come to a conclusion within weeks because thousands of students have already started applying for university places for next autumn.

Last month, the first set of statistics on applications to university next year, published by the Universities and Colleges and Admissions Service (Ucas), showed a near 12% drop in the number of UK-born candidates.

The decision to treble fees was a "major policy change affecting the life chances of a generation of students and billions of pounds of public expenditure", the documents outlining the claimants argument say. "Such a decision should not have been taken without the appropriate degree of rigorous attention to equality needs."

Hurley was one of the thousands of demonstrators kettled during the student protests in December.

Speaking outside the Royal Courts of Justice in London, he said he was representing thousands of students from poor backgrounds who would be deterred from applying to university because of how much they would have to pay back after they graduated. Neither of his parents went to university.

Hurley, who is from Peterborough and is studying for a BTec in software development, said the government ignored protests: "Taking legal action will achieve much more."

Moore, who is studying for A-levels at an academy school in south London, said her peers were confused about how much they would pay in tuition fees once they graduated. "This makes it difficult to decide what to do about our futures," she said.
 
See: 
 
The Guardian
 
BBC
 
Huffington Post
 
Press Association
 
AFP
 
Peterborough Today
 
FMWF


Other stories

Click on a story to read

  Media Comment: Bad Month for MoJ...
  'No justice in sight for Iraqi victims of alleged murder, rape, and torture'...
  At least 30 other 'Baha Mousa' style killings ...
  Press Release : Coalition Minister is ‘Minded to’ Duck Out of Library Inquiry....
  PIL Maintains Top Rankings in Chambers UK Guide 2015. ...
  PIL Concerned by Investigation Into Grieving Daughter...
  Grayling to Auction Off Probation Service...
  The Times reports on the LAA investigation into PIL ...
  Yet more unchecked mass surveillance operations come to light...
  PIL welcomes House of Lords amendments to the Criminal Justice and Courts Bill...
  PIL disappointed with UK’s regression in gender equality...
  Homosexual Asylum Seekers Face Intrusive and Inappropriate Questioning...
  Blackwater Security Guards found guilty of murder of Iraqi civilians in 2007...
  Coalition of charities highlights outrageous government policy...
  Daily Star: Sick ex-soldier demands vital documents from MoD over Gulf War Syndrome...
  Big Issue: Superman isn’t here to protect us but the Human Rights Act is ...
  Independent: Iraq air strikes: Our politicians must remember the lessons from the disastrous 2003 in...
  Iraq air strikes: Our politicians must remember the lessons from the disastrous 2003 invasion of Ira...
  PIL: Grand Chamber ruling in Iraq Camp Bucca disappearance case...
  The Law Society Gazette: Fighting Library Cuts...
  PIL: Court of Appeal hands down its judgment...
  PIL Press Release: Trafficked People have the Right to Recover Damages from their Traffickers Irres...