We have enormous sympathy and the greatest respect for those who have acted with such determination and industry on behalf of the claimant; the case has been conducted on behalf of the claimant with great skill and very considerable restraint and economy….They have substantially succeeded on the issue… and in that success they have sustained a very important public interest under the Convention that otherwise might have gone by default.  We cannot stress too highly our indebtedness to the claimant’s legal team and the necessity for the highest quality of legal representation in cases involving such difficult issues relating to important matters of real public interest.  R (Ali Zaki Mousa (No.2)) v Secretary of State for Defence [2013] EWHC 2941(Admin). Judgment dated 02.10.2013

Rt Hon Sir John Thomas and Honourable Mr Justice Silber
 
 

The Guardian: Child detention in immigration centres faces legal challenge

The Guardian, 26 October 2010, Alan Travis
 
A high court challenge to bring to an immediate end the detention of children in immigration removal centres was launched today.

The case is being brought on behalf of two single mothers and their children who were detained by UK Border Agency (UKBA) officers in dawn raids on their homes earlier this year.

Lawyers acting for Reetha Suppiah and Sakinat Bello say they have evidence that even short periods in detention are unlawful as they cause serious harm to children.

The case, which is expected to last three days, is being brought by Public Interest Lawyers (PIL), with the human rights group Liberty and the campaign group Bail for Immigration Detainees also intervening.

The Home Office said it was fighting the case as it remained committed to the removal of those found by the courts to have no right to remain in the UK.

"The ability to enforce removals when necessary is a key part of a sustainable immigration system," a Home Office spokesman said.

He added that the detention of families would be kept to a minimum while officials drew up an alternative arrangement that would protect the welfare of children without undermining immigration law. The immigration minister, Damian Green, recently assured refugee welfare groups that this work would be completed by the end of the year.

But both PIL and Liberty have accused the coalition government of stalling on its pledge immediately after the election in May that it would end the detention of children for immigration purposes.

Jill Duffy of PIL said that five months after the deputy prime minister, Nick Clegg, called it a moral outrage, children continued to be held in prison-like conditions.

Suppiah and her two sons, aged one and 11, were taken to Yarl's Wood detention centre in Bedfordshire in February and detained for 17 days. Bello was detained at Yarl's Wood for 12 days before being released back into the community. Upon arrival all the children became sick, suffering from diarrhoea and vomiting.

"It appears that the welfare needs of the families were not properly taken into account or even assessed prior to the decision to detain, and the detention experience has had a profound effect upon them," PIL said.

The latest published UKBA figures show that 110 children were detained between April and June this year. Five children were being held in removal centres on 30 June. But more than 1,085 children were detained during the course of 2009. One child was held for 158 days but the average period was two weeks.

Liberty's legal officer, Emma Norton, said: "This has gone on too long and we look to the courts to put an end to it this week. Prison is no place for a child and defending such an unsavoury position is no place for the new government."


Other stories

Click on a story to read

  Al Sweady Inquiry - Closing Written Submissions for the Iraqi Core Participants...
  Phil Shiner on Russia Today talking about British army ‘torture’...
  PIL launch a new Military Justice Unit...
  Radio Times: Chaplain on Marine convicted of Taliban murder: ‘I would probably have shot him too’...
  Phil Shiner to feature on BBC programme about 'Marine A'...
  PIL welcomes peers rejection of proposed changes to ‘statelessness’ laws...
  Open Society Justice Initiative:UK Must Heed Warnings over Statelessness Measure...
  The Guardian: Birmingham joins San Francisco and Oslo in global green cities club...
  The Law Society Gazette: Fog of War...
  PIL's response to the Immigration Bill and statelessness...
  The Birmingham Mail: Lawyer: 'Still Questions to Answer' over Claims British Troops Shot 20 Iraqi M...
  The Independent: Using Statelessness as a Weapon Must be Rejected...
  PIL's concerns about the changes to the Prison Rules...
  Socialist Worker: Al-Sweady Inquiry...
  PIL response to Defence Committee's Report on Remotely Piloted Air Systems...
  PIL rebuttal to The Sun article today – “Spoils of War: Iraq Murder Slurs Lawyers in £2.5m Payday”...
  Phil Shiner: International Lawyer of the Year 2014...
  PIL Press Release: Al Sweady Inquiry ...
  Save Lincolnshire Libraries...
  The Guardian: Soldiers were under bombardment in Iraq, al-Sweady inquiry told...
  The Guardian: British army 'blocked investigation into treatment of Iraqi prisoners'...
  Tony Benn dies...